开源ERP选择
-
[quote author=limin link=topic=17530.msg31966#msg31966 date=1457266018]
本来是想学ODOO的，最近看了网上的相关介绍文章
ODOO目标是替代SAP，ERPnext的目标是替代ODOO
ODOO社区版有免费用户数限制（好像1个还是5个，这样的话和开源精神渐行渐远了吧）,安装复杂。ERPNEXT是印度程序员开发的，好像团队比较小，国内资源少。如果小贸易公司，生产工艺BOM简单，是不是ERPNEXT更适合？
[/quote]
简单的回答下，
1：Odoo曾经想以Sap为目标（主要还是市场推广的目的做的一个宣传），的确基于此引起了一些关注。
但是市场定位不同，软件就会不同，Odoo主要面向的市场是中小企业。
2：Odoo社区版 windows下的绿色版和linuxe下 都没用用户的限制，只有官方的 windows安装版才有，
另外对有点linux基础的人来说，Odoo的安装并不算复杂。
3：Erpnext 据我了解并没有汉化，其他更多的我也不了解，
通常印度人的软件，国内口碑一般，代码写得相对随意。
仅供参考 -
谢谢卓忆。我主要是受了以下这个帖子的影响。
确实，我看NEXTERP用户大多是印度的。不过NEXTERP open resource ERP排名仅在ODOO之下。NEXTERP汉化已经有繁体中文了，简体好像开发者准备用google 翻译。
有没有国内大神做过测试比较的比较适合国内使用环境的，比若说对系统架构，性能，扩展性等比较。毕竟用久了换一个ERP系统比较痛苦的，想一开始就选对。
我个人对国内中小企业定义是贸易销售为主（最好系统现在还要能跟随互联网+的 脚步 ;D，）制造流程和BOM一般比较简单。
<br / https://discuss.erpnext.com/t/erpnext-vs-odoo/7496/4 br />I first was looking only for CRM, but then my "needs" (wants?) expanded to something more like ERP. I struggled with Odoo for nearly 2 months before arriving at (and currently testing) ERPnext. I am very excited about ERPnext and hope that as my company grows we will be able to support ERPnext and help sustain it as a fully open-source project.
Until last week I thought my only choices were Odoo & Bitrix24. But in testing, both of them disappointed me, and here's why:
Bitrix24:
- CRM and intranet, not really ERP
- Pleasant UI
- Instant deployment
- Free up to 12 users
- Many problems with email
- Lack of customization
- For ≥13 users, US$100/month
Odoo NEGATIVES:
- Nightmare to install
- Resource hog (very CPU/db/RAM hungry)
- Slow user experience
- Poor scalability (accommodating more users demands more server resources)
- Critical problems such as the program sending emails to clients about internal matters without any warning (customers are "partners" and partners by default get an email when updates are made to their account… UNACCEPTABLE)
- No flat discount (only percentage, and it's on the item line)
- Next version (Odoo 9) will have limited features in the community edition
- Too many mobile apps, none of the free ones worked well enough for me
- UI is too complex and colors are dull
- Community support is inconsistent; can be difficult to get an answer
- Ugly invoices require serious programming to look better
- "Inbox" functionality makes no sense to me
- Lead creation from emails
Odoo POSITIVES:
Very comprehensive
Automated actions — these are powerful and important
Free
Many third-party addons and a few paid mobile apps
Graphs and charts
Projects
Here's why I'm trying ERPnext and my first impressions:
Runs super fast compared to Odoo (on VPS)
Unbelievably easy install using Bitnami
"Just works" so far, out of the box
Multiple catch-all email addresses (but having problems, more below)
Community seems more supportive and friendly
Flat discount
Email notification functions appear to work well
Nice-looking invoices
Letterhead
On the downside:
I'm having problems with the mail-to-lead functionality: I have set incoming emails to create an opportunity, and yet the opportunities appear blank. The body of the email, the name, the email address — none of that is there, only the subject line. In PDF print mode, I do get the email address. And if set to forward, I do receive the original message in an email. But not in the web app or mobile app.
Automated actions: I don't see that there's currently a clear way to do this in ERPnext (for example, upon entering an installation date, automatically schedule a call to set up a maintenance visit in one year and schedule a maintenance deadline)
Some of the terms are in Indian English, rather than international English, but this is minor
Features I would love to see in future iterations of ERPnext:
- In the Android app: popup notifications, option to call a contact via the cellphone from within the app, and CalDAV/CardDAV calendar/contact synching (or is it already an option?)
- iOS app
- Webmail integration for email from my domain, so employees never have to leave ERPnext (and with menu options to add leads or project tasks from emails or selected email text)
ERPnext team, please keep up the good work!
Peter
